The American Library Association reported in 2023, Hoosiers challenged 346 books with LGBTQ+ themes, people of color as the main characters and the Bible in statewide libraries. Adobe Stock photo provided by INNS.

By Terri Dee
Indiana News Service

INDIANAPOLIS — As the nation prepares for the second term of President-elect Donald Trump, librarians are increasingly worried about his agenda and what it might mean for their bookshelves.

The conservative-leaning playbook known as Project 2025 would overhaul government agencies, cut budgets, increase censorship and reduce civil rights enforcement, according to the EveryLibrary Institute.

Peter Bromberg, associate director of EveryLibrary, said it could spell trouble for public and school libraries when books are labeled “pornographic” for containing LGBTQ+ material.

“What is getting banned as pornographic are mainstream books, are classic books or award-winning books,” Bromberg pointed out. “Even picture books like ‘And Tango Makes Three,’ ‘Heather Has Two Mommies’ or a biography of Billie Jean King that’s a picture book that’s age-appropriate, but it mentions that she’s a gay woman.”

Other books under scrutiny in Indiana contain racially themed or feminist material. A 2023 report from the American Library Association said there were 16 attempts to restrict access to books in Indiana. That year, the Hamilton East Public Library Board’s book ban decisions received national attention.

Also in 2023, Gov. Eric Holcomb signed a bill into law saying school libraries cannot claim legal protection by using “educational reasons” for sharing questionable books with minors.

Despite the publicity book bans get, they are not growing in popularity. A library association survey found most voters support librarians’ authority over what’s on the shelves. But Bromberg emphasized partisan divisiveness persists.

“Once groups are formed and money starts coming in to fund these types of political projects, and I think as we’ve seen, as we continue to see, people’s anger and people’s distrust and people’s fear can be weaponized and can be hijacked towards political ends,” Bromberg contended.

A book is considered “banned” when it is completely removed from a library’s collection, and “restricted” when it’s relocated to a section away from minors. The library association reported just over 100 books appeared on a banned book list last year in Indiana, including the Bible and works written by Nobel Peace Prize and National Book Award winners.